$bbtitle
Apple Stock: 196.19 ( +2.07 )
RSS RSS Twitter Twitter
Search:
AppleInsider.com Archives News Bytes Reviews Anonymous Mailer Submit Story AppleInsider Forums Mac Prices Polls Advertise on AppleInsider Contact AppleInsider
Save over $268 on MacBook Pros and $150 on iMacs with special coupons: Mac Pricing Guide updated Feb. 9th (Find the best prices on Macs).
Tuesday, November 24, 2009

Apple seeks permanent injunction to prevent Psystar sales

By Neil Hughes

Published: 03:40 PM EST

iPad hands-on preview
Apple this week requested a permanent injunction against clone Mac maker Psystar that would prevent it from selling machines with Mac OS X and assisting others to install the operating system on unauthorized machines.

In a filing with Judge William Alsup made Monday, Apple asserted that it is entitled to a permanent judgment against Psystar under the U.S. Copyright Act and Digital Millennium Copyright Act. Apple has argued that Psystar's continued business will irreparably harm Apple, and that Psystar has also spawned other infringers by "trafficking in circumvention devices."

In October, the company began to license its virtualization technology to third-party hardware vendors with a product named Rebel EFI. The Psystar OEM Licensing Program intends to allow manufacturers of Intel machines other than Apple to run Mac OS X 10.6.

Apple also said that the amount of damages that the Florida corporation is capable of paying are inadequate. The filing alleges that Psystar's costs exceeded its revenues in both 2008 and 2009, and the value of its assets, according to its bankruptcy filings, are less than $50,000.

"Even if Psystar could pay damages, the harm to Apple's brand, reputation and goodwill is unquantifiable," Apple said.

The filing includes an affidavit declaration from Phil Schiller, Apple's senior vice president of Worldwide Product Marketing. Schiller found himself at the center of the Psystar controversy when the Florida company accused him of being "unprepared" for testimony. Schiller met with Psystar's lawyers for a deposition that Apple alleged was "nothing more than an effort to harass" him.

Schiller's affidavit filed this week attempts to convince the court to side with Apple, based on the logic that it would be a waste for Apple to have to file another suit.

"So long as Psystar continues these practices, the harm to Apple and its brand will continue," he said in the affidavit. "I believe Apple should not be required to file a new lawsuit to stop Psystar from infringing Apple's intellectual property each time Apple releases a new version of Mac OS X. Requiring Apple to file multiple lawsuits to stop the same infringing conduct would be unfair, expensive, and a waste of the Court's and the parties' resources."

A motion hearing has been scheduled for Dec. 14 in a San Francisco court.

The tide of the lawsuit officially turned in Apple's favor last week, when the Mac maker won a number of decisions in a preliminary judgment from Alsup. The court ruled that Psystar infringed on copyrights owned by Apple in order to place Mac OS X on unauthorized computers built and sold by the company. In addition, they were found to be in violation of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act by circumventing Apple's protection barrier that prevents installation of its operating system on third-party hardware. The decision came after both parties requested summary judgments.

Filed under : General 95 Comments ] 
Story topics: lawsuits, Psystar   Print ] [ Story Link ] 



Mac Poker players can play Full Tilt Poker for Mac and get 100% to $600 free with bonus code MP600, courtesy of Online Poker Mac
AppleInsider Features
Hot Forum Topics

Recent Articles
Parallels takes virtualization speed crown in head-to-head with VMware
Apple releases iPhone OS 3.2 SDK for iPad
Apple seen extending exclusive iPhone deal with AT&T
iTunes price increases mean slower sales for music labels
Apple introduces 64-bit Aperture 3 with Faces and Places
Apple's share of U.S. smartphone market grows to 25% - study
iPhone OS 3.1.3 sees 14% adoption in 6 days, new hack released
Amazon rethinking Kindle in the wake of Apple iPad
Purported 4th gen Apple iPhone parts show largely unchanged design
Execs say Apple could lower iPad price if market demands it - report
Consumers lose interest in iPad after Apple's unveiling - survey
Higher Amazon e-book prices expected to coincide with iPad launch
Inside Apple's iPad: VGA video output
Unannounced Core i7 Apple MacBook Pro surfaces in benchmarks logs
Apple's new beta of Mac OS X 10.6.3 includes few changes
One in five physicians likely to purchase Apple iPad - study
Sling Media says it didn't change iPhone SlingPlayer to appease AT&T
Credit Suisse: 75% chance AT&T keeps iPhone exclusivity in 2010
Apple denying iPhone apps that use location framework for targeted ads
Apple's iPad deal gives Hachette pricing leverage against Amazon
Eccentric but effective Steve Jobs pitches iPad to NYT execs
Owners of flickering 27-inch iMacs claim 15% refund from Apple
IDC: Apple iPhone was No. 3 smartphone in 2009 with 14.4% of market
Future Apple iPhones could share current location during a call
AT&T, Sling Media partner to allow 3G access on iPhone SlingPlayer
Apple's iTunes Preview now offers browser-based App Store access
Amazon acquires touch-screen maker for future Kindle project
Nehalem Mac Pro systems suffer audio-based performance issues
Two new hires are Apple's latest moves in mobile advertising
AT&T outbid Verizon with cheaper Apple iPad data plans - rumor
Apple seen moving 2M iPads in 2010 before sales 'catalyst' emerges
Apple iPad deal pushes another publisher to renegotiate with Amazon
Apple allegedly selects new manufacturer for next-gen iPhone
ScrollMotion tapped by publishers to develop textbook apps for iPad
Apple denies iMac production halt as shipment times improve
Apple releases iPhone OS 3.1.3 with battery reporting fix
U.S. senator presses Apple on human rights practices in China
Photo of Apple's next-generation iPhone in the wild - sources
Despite sales growth, Apple's iPhone loses market share - report
Intel 6-core i7-powered Mac Pro rumored to launch this month

 
Advertisements








AppleInsider RSS Feed
AppleInsider © 1997-2008
Please review our Privacy Policy.
Written/Edited/Compiled by the AppleInsider Staff.