$bbtitle
Apple Stock: 196.19 ( 0.00 )
RSS RSS Twitter Twitter
Search:
AppleInsider.com Archives News Bytes Reviews Anonymous Mailer Submit Story AppleInsider Forums Mac Prices Polls Advertise on AppleInsider Contact AppleInsider
Save over $268 on MacBook Pros and $150 on iMacs with special coupons: Mac Pricing Guide updated Feb. 9th (Find the best prices on Macs).
Friday, August 21, 2009

Psystar claims Apple exec "unprepared" for testimony

By Neil Hughes

Published: 12:25 PM EST

iPad hands-on preview
In the latest court filings from the ongoing Apple lawsuit against Psystar, the clone Mac maker accuses Apple executive Phil Schiller of being "unprepared" for his deposition, while the Cupertino, Calif., company seeks to keep its profit margins private.

Last week, Psystar, via its official blog, boasted that it would give Apple officials "a taste of their own medicine," and provided a list of executives who would be deposed. Included was a deposition with Apple's senior vice president of Worldwide Product Marketing, Phil Schiller, scheduled for Aug. 14.

Psystar's deposition of Schiller apparently did not go as the defendant had hoped it would, as the company filed a complaint this week alleging the Apple executive was "wholly unprepared and unwilling to testify" about injuries his company claims to have suffered. Apple has alleged that Psystar's knock-off PCs install Mac OS X by circumventing the software's copy protection and violate the Digital Millennium Copyright Act. According to Psystar's filing, from counsel David Welker, Schiller did not answer questions asked during the deposition. The heavily-redacted document does not include descriptions of the events.

"Apple's furnishing a witness on injury who was wholly unprepared to testify about that subject is a discovery violation that relates to a core issue in this case, the harm, if any, that Apple suffered as a result of Psystar's conduct," Psystar's filing reads. "Psystar respectfully requests that this Court (1) order Apple to properly prepare Mr. Schiller for his deposition as a corporate representative on injury, (2) require that Mr. Schiller appear for a continuation of his deposition in Houston, at the offices of Psystar's lead counsel, within the next fourteen days, and (3) pay Psystar's attorneys' fees associated with Mr. Schiller's deposition, this brief, and any subsequent proceedings."

Apple responded by filing a document in which it said that Psystar's deposition of Schiller was "nothing more than an effort to harass one of Apple's senior executives and prematurely seek expert testimony." It states that the letter from Psystar leaves out key facts, and asks that the request to re-depose Schiller be denied.

"Despite Apple's objections, Psystar's counsel sought testimony on the quantification of damages -- the subject of expert testimony -- rather than the injury suffered by Apple..." the filing from the Townsend Law Firm reads. "Mr. Schiller was fully prepared to discuss the non-quantifiable injury to Apple but Psystar's counsel chose to not ask those questions and terminated the deposition instead."

In another twist, Apple has told the court it will not seek recovery of lost profits from Psystar. The decision came after Apple allegedly reviewed the "still-incomplete financial records" provided by the company, which recently emerged from bankruptcy.

It goes on to say that Apple's internal profit margin data is "closely guarded," and the risk of that information being leaked is not worth the lost profits it might be able to obtain from Psystar. As a result, Apple is no longer seeking those lost profits for recovery in the suit.

"In light of Apple's decision not to seek lost profits and Psystar's stated intent to disclose Apple's confidential information, Apple now seeks a protective order specifically precluding the discovery by Psystar of Apple's non-public profit margins on the sale of individual products or product lines," Apple's filing states. "Indeed, Apple believes that discovery of its non-public financial information should be limited to revenues, R&D and advertising costs related to Mac computers and Mac OS X."

Earlier this month, Apple sent its own laywers to Psystar's Florida headquarters for discovery in the trial, scheduled to start in 2010.

Filed under : General 79 Comments ] 
Story topics: lawsuits, Psystar   Print ] [ Story Link ] 



Mac Poker players can play Full Tilt Poker for Mac and get 100% to $600 free with bonus code MP600, courtesy of Online Poker Mac
AppleInsider Features
Hot Forum Topics

Recent Articles
Parallels takes virtualization speed crown in head-to-head with VMware
Apple releases iPhone OS 3.2 SDK for iPad
Apple seen extending exclusive iPhone deal with AT&T
iTunes price increases mean slower sales for music labels
Apple introduces 64-bit Aperture 3 with Faces and Places
Apple's share of U.S. smartphone market grows to 25% - study
iPhone OS 3.1.3 sees 14% adoption in 6 days, new hack released
Amazon rethinking Kindle in the wake of Apple iPad
Purported 4th gen Apple iPhone parts show largely unchanged design
Execs say Apple could lower iPad price if market demands it - report
Consumers lose interest in iPad after Apple's unveiling - survey
Higher Amazon e-book prices expected to coincide with iPad launch
Inside Apple's iPad: VGA video output
Unannounced Core i7 Apple MacBook Pro surfaces in benchmarks logs
Apple's new beta of Mac OS X 10.6.3 includes few changes
One in five physicians likely to purchase Apple iPad - study
Sling Media says it didn't change iPhone SlingPlayer to appease AT&T
Credit Suisse: 75% chance AT&T keeps iPhone exclusivity in 2010
Apple denying iPhone apps that use location framework for targeted ads
Apple's iPad deal gives Hachette pricing leverage against Amazon
Eccentric but effective Steve Jobs pitches iPad to NYT execs
Owners of flickering 27-inch iMacs claim 15% refund from Apple
IDC: Apple iPhone was No. 3 smartphone in 2009 with 14.4% of market
Future Apple iPhones could share current location during a call
AT&T, Sling Media partner to allow 3G access on iPhone SlingPlayer
Apple's iTunes Preview now offers browser-based App Store access
Amazon acquires touch-screen maker for future Kindle project
Nehalem Mac Pro systems suffer audio-based performance issues
Two new hires are Apple's latest moves in mobile advertising
AT&T outbid Verizon with cheaper Apple iPad data plans - rumor
Apple seen moving 2M iPads in 2010 before sales 'catalyst' emerges
Apple iPad deal pushes another publisher to renegotiate with Amazon
Apple allegedly selects new manufacturer for next-gen iPhone
ScrollMotion tapped by publishers to develop textbook apps for iPad
Apple denies iMac production halt as shipment times improve
Apple releases iPhone OS 3.1.3 with battery reporting fix
U.S. senator presses Apple on human rights practices in China
Photo of Apple's next-generation iPhone in the wild - sources
Despite sales growth, Apple's iPhone loses market share - report
Intel 6-core i7-powered Mac Pro rumored to launch this month

 
Advertisements








AppleInsider RSS Feed
AppleInsider © 1997-2008
Please review our Privacy Policy.
Written/Edited/Compiled by the AppleInsider Staff.