$bbtitle
Apple Stock: 189.87 ( +0.92 )
RSS RSS Twitter Twitter
Search:
AppleInsider.com Archives News Bytes Reviews Anonymous Mailer Submit Story AppleInsider Forums Mac Prices Polls Advertise on AppleInsider Contact AppleInsider
Black Friday Deals Extended: save up to $300 on MacBook Pros and up to $180 on iMacs: Mac Pricing Guide updated Dec 8th (Find the best prices on Macs).
Thursday, April 23, 2009

Steve Jobs testifies to feeling underappreciated by Apple board

By Kasper Jade

Published: 05:15 PM EST

Roughly four years after returning to Apple, Steve Jobs had set the company on course for one of the most remarkable comebacks in Silicon Valley history but says he felt underappreciated by his board of directors and as a result asked for a sizable stock grant that would later play a major role in the company's widely publicized option-backdating scandal.

Leveraging the Freedom of Information Act, Forbes magazine was able to obtain a transcript of the 119-page deposition Jobs gave to the Securities and Exchange Commission last year regarding the role of his former general counsel Nancy Heinen in matter. He was also probed in regard to his knowledge of the situation and whether he fully understood the implications of backdating stock options.

Apple was one of dozens of companies to come under investigation by the SEC after it disclosed late in December of 2006 that an internal audit had turned up irregularities in 6,428 option grants. Although Jobs was never charged with any wrongdoing, Heinen and former chief financial officer Fred Anderson were separately indicted for their roles in the backdating of two large grants given to Jobs and other members of Apple's top brass.

Both Anderson and Heinen -- who was also accused of fabricating minutes of a phantom board meeting that never took place -- resigned (1, 2) from Apple ahead of the formal charges and ultimately went on to strike deals with the SEC by which they agreed, without admitting any wrongdoing, to hefty fines and the disgorgement of proceeds received from exercising their own backdated options.

In March of 2008, representatives for the SEC interviewed Jobs for three hours at Apple's Cupertino-based campus as part of their case against Heinen. Throughout the meeting, Jobs maintained that he lacked a general understanding of Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) and options backdating, and in many cases stated that he didn't know or could not recall the answers to the investigator's questions.

More interesting, however, was Jobs' disclosure that he alone in 2001 requested the 7.5 million share options grant, later revealed to have been backdated, because he wasn't feeling appreciated by his directors for his efforts, especially with all of his prior stock options haven fallen underwater when the dot-com bubble burst. Jobs later traded the grant for restricted stock units with less value.

"It wasn't so much about the money," he testified. "Everybody likes to be recognized by his peers. ... I felt that the board wasn't really doing the same with me. [...] I just felt like there is nobody looking out for me here, you know. ... So I wanted them to do something, and so we talked about it. ... I thought I was doing a pretty good job."

Jobs, who added that it would "have made him feel better" had the board proposed the grant on its own, said the options were approved during an August 2001 meeting when Apple shares were at $17.83 but that he continued to debate the vesting terms of the options with the board, which caused the company to miss a filing deadline. Option backdating isn't illegal as long as a company properly accounts for the move in its financial disclosures.

Both sides finally hammered out the fine points of the grant on December 18th, but by then Apple's shares had risen to $21.01. The decision was ultimately made to backdate the grant to October 19th when the share price was at $18.30, which led to the minutes of the original August board meeting being doctor and those for a non-existant October meeting crafted out of thin air.

In the deposition obtained by Forbes, Jobs denied any knowledge of the falsified meeting minutes until the scandal became public and said another grant of 4.8 million backdated options to top Apple executives -- including Anderson and Heinen -- was critical to keeping his executive branch intact.

"I was very concerned because Michael Dell, one of our chief competitors, had flown Fred Anderson, our CFO, down to Austin ... to try and recruit him," Jobs said, adding that Dell had several other Apple managers in its sights as well.

In late December of 2006, Apple announced that it would incur a total additional non-cash stock-based compensation expense of $84 million after tax, including $4 million and $7 million in fiscal years 2006 and 2005, respectively, to square itself with the federal government as a result of the backdating mess.

For his part, Anderson has maintained that Jobs played a role in the backdating of the executive team grant and that he had a better understanding of the general accounting principles than Apple led the public to believe.

Filed under : General 63 Comments ] 
Story topics: Steve Jobs   Print ] [ Story Link ] 


Download Parallels 5.0 Today
RSS
RSS
RSS
Mac Poker players can play Full Tilt Poker for Mac and get 100% to $600 free with bonus code MP600, courtesy of Online Poker Mac
AppleInsider Features
Hot Forum Topics

Recent Articles
Apple preparing first betas of Mac OS X 10.6.3
Apple's recent stock drop not seen as cause for panic
Apple's Lala purchase price disputed, Kodak storewide sale, more
Google Chrome for Mac Web browser reaches beta release
Major print publishers confirm collaborative digital store
Apple reveals best-selling iTunes content, iPhone apps of 2009
Apple appeals $21.7 million patent infringement decision
Review scam leads to removal of over 1,000 apps from App Store
Apple reportedly spent $80 million to acquire Lala
Apple sold estimated 60,000 iPhones in South Korean launch
'Mark the Spot' iPhone app aims to find AT&T trouble areas
Apple's Lala purchase forecasts browser access to iTunes content
iPod touch use outpaces iPhone, could foster Apple loyalty - report
Comcast's NBC deal could be roadblock for Apple's subscription hopes
Microsoft alters settlement with EU over browser exclusivity
Reports confirm Apple reaches agreement to purchase Lala
Apple close to acquiring music streaming service Lala - report
Apple's iMac, MacBook Pro top U.S. October PC sales
Apple ordered to pay $21.7 million in patent suit
Apple adds 3.33GHz quad-core Mac Pro, 2TB hard drive upgrades
Motorola suggests Apple's iPhone is feminine in latest TV spot
Progress made on Apple's potential second Cupertino campus
Publisher Hearst releases plans for digital magazine, newspaper service
College develops iPhone app to connect with potential students
Google launches free Public DNS
Intel to apply Apple's App Store strategy with netbooks
China's largest e-commerce site sells 5 iPhones in 2 weeks
Mac sales projected to grow 26% in 2010, outpacing PC market
Apple predicted to offer 300,000 iPhone apps, tablet in 2010
Time Inc. demos tablet-friendly magazine concept
Retailers want in on Apple's iPod touch point-of-sale system
Apple tablet rumored to be 'shockingly' inexpensive
AT&T drops lawsuit against Verizon over advertising spat
After Apple agreement, Psystar officially halts sales of clone Macs
'Complicated' Verizon iPhone deal said to be unlikely in 2010
Apple's Cyber Monday Internet shopping traffic increases 71%
Psystar agrees to pay Apple $2.7M in settlement
Apple's iPhone predicted to find home at T-Mobile U.S. in 2010
AT&T ranks last in Consumer Reports mobile service survey
Google hopes to compete with iTunes, offer pay TV on YouTube

AppleInsider Market Place

Sell your Laptop - working or not. Free shipping.: Get an instant online quote and sell your laptop today !

Believe in Office: Save Up To 25% on Office 2004 For Mac. Visit Our Site for Details!

IBackup - SMB Online Backup: IBackup is the preferred online storage and backup service of choice for SMBs for its ease of use, security and value. Offers automated backup and restore, file selection and securiy.

Download free software - everyday updated freeware files

 
Advertisements








AppleInsider RSS Feed
AppleInsider © 1997-2008
Please review our Privacy Policy.
Written/Edited/Compiled by the AppleInsider Staff.