$bbtitle
AAPL: 90.02 ( -2.65 ) AppleInsider RSS Feed
Search:
AppleInsider.com Archives Reviews Anonymous Mailer Submit Story AppleInsider Forums Polls Advertise on AppleInsider Contact AppleInsider
Run Windows on your Mac: Download Parallels 4.0 today. Now 50% faster. Upgrades: $39.99. New licenses $79.99.
Wednesday, October 15, 2008

Luxpro finally sues Apple to defend iPod shuffle clone

By Aidan Malley

Published: 07:55 PM EST

Living up to a promise it made in January 2007, Taiwanese electronics maker Luxpro has at last filed a lawsuit against Apple claiming that the American company was plotting a multinational scheme when it sued Luxpro over its iPod shuffle doppelganger.

The 19-page suit, submitted on Tuesday to a court in Texarkana, Arkansas, not only accuses Apple of trying to unlawfully interfere with Luxpro's business but of an "unending aspiration" to hold a monopoly over the entire world's supply of portable media players that crushes smaller players underfoot.

Reading more as a promotional piece for the company's business than a direct complaint, the lawsuit says Apple's own legal action in 2005 to shut down sales of the allegedly infringing Super Tangent stemmed from a need to "crush" smaller manufacturers before they became larger, which Luxpro insists was well underway thanks to features Apple didn't have and distribution deals in Canada, China and the US -- a 7,000 unit trial with The Source (Radio Shack) in Canada saw the similarly-designed Top Tangent 'fly' off of shelves, Luxpro is proud to state.

The smaller player does take care to formally charge Apple, insisting the iPod maker is interfering with lawful contracts and violating California's Unfair Competition Law to get its monopoly, but is more concerned with the motives.

Besides tying purchased iTunes Store songs to the iPod, Apple has allegedly used "unfair" legal tactics simply to squash competitors, including countersuing Creative in a patent dispute to force a settlement and let it use licenses for the ZEN maker's patents to subdue competitors. Apple knows many smaller companies are growing faster and can't let that happen, Luxpro claims.

And though the purportedly offending Super Tangent player shipped months after the first iPod shuffle, was originally called the Super Shuffle, and bore an uncanny resemblance to the iPod, Apple was reportedly attempting solely to intimidate and take down Luxpro when it took action at trade shows and in the marketplace to stop the 'obviously' different Tangent series of players from being marketed and sold.

iPod shuffle versus Luxpro Super Tangent


This is also said to have included bullying by proxy: Apple allegedly went through ASUS to force a Polish importer to stop carrying Luxpro's goods, achieving the intended effect while letting Apple "erase its fingerprints" left on the affair.

That hurt Luxpro's chances to get on the GraTei securities market and soured deals with suppliers, the plaintiff adds. Even after Taiwan's Fair Trade Commission exonerated Luxpro, the company had lost months of player orders. Apple is now known to be continuing appeals in court against the FTC that have been submitted as recently as February of this year.

For all its certainty regarding Apple's intent and approach, Luxpro has notably backed off from its aggressive damage claims: where it once said it would ask for as much as $100 million from Apple for lost business, the Taiwan company now says the final amount should be determined by a jury at trial.

In its typical fashion, Apple hasn't commented on the lawsuit or Luxpro's accusations.

Filed under : iPod 20 Comments ] 
Story topics: lawsuits, Luxpro, iPod shuffle   Print ] [ Story Link ] 


Parallels 4.0
Mac Poker players can play Full Tilt Poker for Mac and get 100% to $600 free with bonus code MP600, courtesy of Online Poker Mac
AppleInsider Features
Hot Forum Topics

Recent Articles
VMWare offering 50% off Fusion 2.0 for Cyber Monday
iPhone Dev Team successfully boots Linux on iPhone
Black Friday Mac pricing matrix (find the best prices)
Apple's Black Friday Sale: $101 off some MacBooks and iMacs
Black Friday at Amazon: cameras, GPS, hard drives, and more
Black Friday: Office 2008, Parallels, Quicken, Adobe
Google testing Picasa for Mac beta
iPhone 2.2 hides video out code for third-party apps
Apple investigating graphics issues on new MacBook lines
Early deals: $250 off new MacBook Pros, $325 off Office 2008
Apple's Black Friday discounts may rise to 15%, says firm
QuickTime 7.5.7 allows SD iTunes playback over DisplayPort
Mac small business share nearly triples over the summer
Apple's unadvertised retail store price matching policy
Talks to bring The Beatles to iTunes break down
Piper Jaffray addresses 12 more 'unanswered Apple questions'
Apple lays claim to greenest notebooks ever in new ad campaign
Apple stock surges on belief MacBooks "peel away" Windows users
Apple sued over mobile Safari as email retention policy questioned
Microsoft developing NVIDIA-based mobile phone - report
LG holds iMac-suitable touchscreen; new iTunes plus hints
Best Buy cuts prices on Apple's Mac line for 4-day sale [u]
Apple, Palm taking different steps to reduce worker overhead
Dining out with iPhone: Zagat and OpenTable hit the App Store
Apple updates Final Cut Pro, Compressor, Color, and Shake
Apple releases iPhone Software v2.2
Apple releases iTunes 8.0.2 ahead of iPhone software 2.2
iPhone security posting suggests 2.2 firmware tomorrow
Apple now No. 2 in corporate smartphone market share
Review roundup: RIM's new touchscreen BlackBerry Storm
Apple authorizes MMS on the iPhone, but not for US users
Apple developing always-on iPhone status indicators
Apple releases Apple TV 2.3 with AirTunes, third-party remotes
Apple's OpenCL standard near complete in just six months
Apple in talks to offer more DRM-free tracks on iTunes [updated]
Microsoft saw Apple's anti-Vista campaign coming
Wal-Mart to begin selling iPhone post holidays - reports
Apple waiting on quad-core desktop chips from Intel
Apple may release Snow Leopard early next year
Reseller sells early MacBook Air prototype on eBay

AppleInsider Market Place

Sell your Laptop - working or not. Free shipping.: Get an instant online quote and sell your laptop today !

Believe in Office: Save Up To 25% on Office 2004 For Mac. Visit Our Site for Details!

IBackup - SMB Online Backup: IBackup is the preferred online storage and backup service of choice for SMBs for its ease of use, security and value. Offers automated backup and restore, file selection and securiy.

Download free software - everyday updated freeware files

 
Advertisements








AppleInsider RSS Feed
AppleInsider © 1997-2008
Please review our Privacy Policy.
Written/Edited/Compiled by the AppleInsider Staff.