$bbtitle
AAPL: 96.80 ( +8.06 ) AppleInsider RSS Feed
Search:
AppleInsider.com Archives Reviews Anonymous Mailer Submit Story AppleInsider Forums Polls Advertise on AppleInsider Contact AppleInsider
Pre-order Adobe CS4: Web Premium CS4, Design Premium CS4, Production Premium CS4, Master Collection CS4.
Friday, September 28, 2007

Apple, Jobs, AT&T sued over iPhone price cut, rebates

By Kasper Jade

Published: 01:00 PM EST

Apple Inc., along with its chief executive and exclusive U.S. iPhone wireless partner AT&T, have been hit with a new lawsuit from a disgruntled customer who charges the trio with a variety of offenses stemming from the recent iPhone price cut.

In the suit, filed Sept. 24 in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of New York, Queens resident Dongmei Li accuses the parties of price discrimination, underselling, discrimination in rebates, deceptive actions, and other wrongdoings for their role in the Sept. 5th price drop on iPhone, which saw the handset's price tag slashed an unprecedented $200 less than two months after its debut.

Li was among the thousands who waited hours in line on June 29, 2007 for her chance to purchase one of the touch-screen devices, according to the suit. When she reached the front of the line, her local Apple store only had 4GB models remaining, which she purchased anyway despite having intended to buy the larger-capacitied 8GB model.

She, like thousands of others, the suit claims, is now the victim of price discrimination in that she cannot resell her iPhone for the same profit as customers who purchased the device after price drop. Similarly, she cannot trade up to 8GB model she had initially hoped to obtain and is now left with a product that has been discontinued.

Li also feels cheated by Apple's rebate policy because she was only offered a $100 store credit towards a future Apple store purchase when those customers who bought the same iPhone within a two week window period immediately preceding the cut received the full $200 refund under the company's price protection policy.

Li included in her 8-page complaint historical stock graphs that show Apple's share price to have risen in between the time it released iPhone in late June and when the company instated the price cut. She argues that this is proof that there was no sound reason for the cut, which she equated to "underselling."

"Market conditions did not require Apple to change its price," Li's attorney, C. Jean Wang of Wang Law Offices, PLLC wrote in the filing. "iPhone was selling very well because Apple's stocks were increasing since August 16, 2007 and rose as high as $144.16 on September 4, 2007, the day before Apple announced that it was cutting the price of iPhone."

The lawsuit goes on to accuse Apple, Jobs and AT&T of forcing customers into 2-year service agreements with AT&T and imposing hefty $175 termination fees. These requirements are unfair, the suit continues, because customers who purchased the iPhone later in the year were able to utilize unlocking solutions that allowed them to forgo such terms and fees.

Given Apple's since stated stance on this matter -- and the recent consequences faced by users of unlocked iPhones in recent days -- it would seem this portion of the suit is now of lesser merit.

For those claims which the Court is still likely to take into account, Li is requesting compensatory damages in the amount of $1 million, punitive damages in the amount to be determined at trial, and a court order that she is entitled to "threefold her damages , the costs involved in maintaining this action, and attorney's fees."

129 Comments ] 
  Print ] [ Story Link ] 

Mac Poker players can play Full Tilt Poker for Mac and get 100% to $600 free with bonus code MP600, courtesy of Online Poker Mac
AppleInsider Features
Hot Forum Topics

Recent Articles
NVIDIA platform claimed likely for new MacBook line
Google working to target iPhone ad market
Apple says some MacBook Pros affected by faulty Nvidia chips
Notes of interest on recent Apple MacBook case leaks
Apple releases Security Update 2008-007 for Mac OS X
Piper Jaffray says new MacBooks could be priced from $899
Apple makes October 14th MacBook event official
Sources: latest MacBook Pro photo is the real deal
Apple Launches iPhone Tech Talk World Tour
New photo may reveal more of Apple's next-gen MacBook Pro
Apple cancels Colorado call center citing economy, reduced iPhone calls
Apple awarded patent on the Dock
Apple launches "Field Trip to the Apple Store" program
Window for rumored October 14 Apple event closing
Analysts slash 2009 mobile phone market growth predictions
BlackBerry Storm debuts with app store, Mac suite on the way
Apple pulling away from competition in teenage mindshare
Apple co-founder believes iPod has about run its course
Apple calls on lawyers in logo spat with Canadian school [updated]
Margin impact of Apple product transitions overestimated
New EU directive pushes toward replaceable iPhone batteries
Apple mellowing its tone on leaks?
iPhone 3G now the second best-selling US mobile handset
Google Street View, auto-correction prefs in iPhone OS 2.2 beta
Data suggests Apple has cruised past 10 million iPhone goal
NVIDIA allegedly showing new MacBooks to staff
Judge waives Apple, AT&T objections to antitrust case vs. iPhone
SEC investigating false report on Steve Jobs heart attack
Latest iPhone Software supports full-screen Web apps
Apple ripe to expand Mac sales to UK's largest phone retailer
Apple denies CNN iReport of Steve Jobs heart attack
Apple TV 2.2 update delivers HDTV shows, Genius support
Apple releases iTunes 8.0.1 to address HDTV episode bug
Nokia answers iPhone's blows with its first touchscreen phone
Copyright board leaves music royalty payments unchanged
AT&T in no rush to build out 4G network
Apple settles class-action suit over faulty notebook adapters
Apple details cursor-based QuickLook and advanced functions
Boxee takes social networks, web video to Apple TV
Apple files motion for dismissal of Psystar counterclaims

AppleInsider Market Place

Sell your Laptop - working or not. Free shipping.: Get an instant online quote and sell your laptop today !

Believe in Office: Save Up To 25% on Office 2004 For Mac. Visit Our Site for Details!

IBackup - SMB Online Backup: IBackup is the preferred online storage and backup service of choice for SMBs for its ease of use, security and value. Offers automated backup and restore, file selection and securiy.

Download free software - everyday updated freeware files

 
Advertisements







AppleInsider RSS Feed
AppleInsider © 1997-2008
Please review our Privacy Policy.
Written/Edited/Compiled by the AppleInsider Staff.