$bbtitle
AAPL: 164.61 ( +2.59 ) AppleInsider RSS Feed
Search:
AppleInsider.com Archives Reviews Anonymous Mailer Submit Story AppleInsider Forums Polls Advertise on AppleInsider Contact AppleInsider
Hot Topics: Moving to iPhone 3G on AT&T , International iPhone 3G Plans , iPhone 3G
Thursday, August 16, 2007

Second class-action suit filed over alleged iPhone battery fraud

By Aidan Malley

Published: 07:00 PM EST

A Bay Area resident is the next to join the ranks of those filing lawsuits against Apple and AT&T, arguing that both companies have tricked customers into paying for frequent battery replacements.

Sydney Leung's nine-page class-action complaint, filed in a Northern District of California court on Monday, accusing both Apple and AT&T of fraud in neglecting to inform potential iPhone buyers of the costs involved in maintaining a working battery for the iPhone over the course of the handset's lifespan.

In a virtual repeat of the argument made by Jose Trujillo in his Illinois lawsuit from July, Leung and his representing lawyers Arthur Lazear and Max Folkenflik claim that the battery in the iPhone will last only 300 complete charges before depleting entirely. And again like Trujillo, the new suit contends that the battery will need to be replaced every year by Apple alone due to the sealed rear compartment, which prevents third-party technicians and users from swapping batteries themselves without voiding the warranty.

The accumulated costs of ordering the replacement, shipping, and the loaner iPhone would amount to over $100 each year on top of the three-day replacement process, the lawsuit claims. But as neither Apple nor AT&T had provided warning about any of the costs involved in maintaining a useful battery until after the launch, customers who had bought iPhones during the June 29th introductory weekend -- including Leung -- were not informed of the time and money required until they were locked into a two-year AT&T service contract.

The scope of the complaint is believed to cover the "hundreds of thousands" of users who had bought iPhones before Apple and AT&T publicized the battery replacement details, and therefore demands a class-action suit on their behalf, Folkenflik and Lazear write. As a representative of the affected iPhone buyers, Leung's party demands a jury trial and hopes to recoup the cost of replacing batteries as well as punitive damages for misleading the first wave of customers.

For its part, Apple has not issued public statements about the suit and continues to contradict the claims of both Leung and Trujillo regarding the cellphone's battery life. The Cupertino, Calif.-based electronics firm officially states on its website that the lithium-ion pack maintains its full charging potential for between 300 and 400 cycles and should still hold the majority of its charge for some time afterwards.

Customers are also not required to spend more than $100 for each replacement, since purchasing the AppleCare plan for iPhones would cover any battery replacements needed during the two years of the AT&T agreement. Users have further reported that the iPhone's SIM card functions on a basic level in many other AT&T phones, allowing customers with existing handsets to waive the $29 fee for a temporary iPhone in the event of a battery swap.

68 Comments ] 
 [ Tell a Friend ] [ Print ] [ Story Link ] 

Mac Poker players can play Full Tilt Poker for Mac and get 100% to $600 free with bonus code MP600, courtesy of Online Poker Mac
AppleInsider Features
Hot Forum Topics

Recent Articles
Steve Jobs in good health following second surgery - report
AT&T developing voice-controlled iPhone apps (video)
Second firm tests Apple's legal resolve with Mac OS X-ready PCs
Server, connectivity problems add to Apple's MobileMe woes [u]
Apple issues quartet of iLife '08 updates
Apple may be eying sub-$1000 notebook market
Microsoft offers first hints at anti-Apple marketing blitz for Vista
Apple shares beaten late on concerns over CEO's health, guidance
Apple plans mystery "product transition" before September's end
Notes of interest for Apple's Q3 2008 financial results call
Apple posts profit of $1.07B, ships nearly 2.5 million Macs
Briefly: Snow Leopard Finder icons support QuickLook
Apple Q3 preview: analysts place bets ahead of earnings
iPhone 3G now all but sold out in 38 states
iPhone 3G jailbreaking tool goes live
iPhone 3G and 2.0 affected by buggy software, sensors, wireless
Apple retail invades China this weekend (photos)
AT&T offers iPhone owners free access to 17,000 WiFi hotspots [u]
Apple hikes orders for notebook boards by 20 percent - report
iPhone 3G shortages causing major delays for AT&T, businesses
App Store downloads led by free apps; one quarter are games
Apple's gross margin may be "biggest swing factor" next week
Apple filing takes Podcasts to the next level
Future Sony HDTVs to embed support for new Amazon video service
Apple may have shipped record 2.54 million Macs in third quarter
Apple passes Acer to become third largest U.S. PC vendor
BlackBerry maker downgraded in light of blistering iPhone sales
Apple apologizes to MobileMe subscribers with free 30-day extension
Apple's iPhone 3G battery good for about 3.5 hours of browsing
iPhone 3G's final build price: just $174.33
PlayStation 3, Xbox 360 now fuller rivals to Apple TV
Apple finally sues unauthorized clone maker Psystar
Apple testing first bug fix update to iPhone Software v2.0
Intel says first quad-core mobile chips on the horizon
iPhone 3G clarifications: battery life, GPS, office apps
A look at who's making iPhone 3G purchases thus far
Apple delays iDisk File Sharing feature of new MobileMe service
Apple sells 1 million iPhone 3Gs in first weekend
iPhone App Store downloads top 10 million in first weekend
Hidden iPhone 3G firmware "fixes" yellow screens

AppleInsider Market Place

Sell your Laptop - working or not. Free shipping.: Get an instant online quote and sell your laptop today !

Believe in Office: Save Up To 25% on Office 2004 For Mac. Visit Our Site for Details!

IBackup - SMB Online Backup: IBackup is the preferred online storage and backup service of choice for SMBs for its ease of use, security and value. Offers automated backup and restore, file selection and securiy.

Download free software - everyday updated freeware files

 
Advertisements







AppleInsider RSS Feed
AppleInsider © 1997-2008
Please review our Privacy Policy.
Written/Edited/Compiled by the AppleInsider Staff.