$bbtitle
Apple Stock: 196.19 ( +2.07 )
RSS RSS Twitter Twitter
Search:
AppleInsider.com Archives News Bytes Reviews Anonymous Mailer Submit Story AppleInsider Forums Mac Prices Polls Advertise on AppleInsider Contact AppleInsider
Save over $268 on MacBook Pros and $150 on iMacs with special coupons: Mac Pricing Guide updated Feb. 9th (Find the best prices on Macs).
Monday, January 22, 2007

Apple faces two-pronged patent lawsuit assault

By Aidan Malley

Published: 07:00 PM EST

A recent pair of lawsuits filed by two relatively small firms target the core Apple's businesses -- including general computer technology and the emblematic iPod scroll wheel.

iPad hands-on preview
While the Cisco iPhone lawsuit continues to draw the greatest amount of attention from the press, less publicized suits revealed only in the past few days threaten both its technical foundations and its cash reserves.

British touch sensor chip maker Quantum Research Group says it filed a formal complaint against Apple in December 2005 over alleged patent infringements based on the iPod's scroll wheel. The suit had remained out of the public eye until Monday, when it was revealed that Apple vehemently denied "all material allegations" involving its interface and had filed a countersuit claiming the invalidity of the patent.

At the heart of the suit is a concern over the control mechanism at the basis of some of Apple's music players. Certain iPod models, including the first- and second-geneartion iPod nanos as well as the iPod with video, use Cypress programmable system-on-chip controllers that Quantum frontman Hal Philipp claims infringes on a patent his company holds for touch sensors. Earlier iPods that use wheels from Synaptics aren't affected, the executive was quick to say.

Philip was equally rapid in his attempts to dismiss notions that the patent was merely opportunistic, expressing hope that the iPhone didn't also contain his firm's technology (which is also present in touchscreens) and affection for his lawsuit's target. "I think Cypress’ PSoC is a fine chip and we are fans of Apple products," he told reporters. "Within hours of the iPhone announcement our phone began to ring. iPhone itself is going to drive specification in terms of capacitive touchscreens."

The lawsuit could still be resolved through an out of court settlement, but the Quantum chief fully expects the case to reach a trial in light of Apple's staunch opposition.

More recently, Apple was also served with a second but far less benign lawsuit by controller chip maker OPTi, which late last week revealed that it was suing the Cupertino company for patent infringement, claiming that Apple violated patents OPTi had been granted for "Predictive Snooping of Cache Memory for Master-Initiated Accesses."

Although seemingly complex, the patent has raised many eyebrows for its overly-broad relevance: the description covers a common technique of cutting overhead from data transfers between a computer's CPU and other components, effectively making just about any CPU or system builder the potential victim of OPTi's legal action.

Indeed, the press release for the lawsuit has suggested that the Mountain View-based controller chip designer is making as vast a claim as possible. OPTi argued that virtually every Mac sold infringes on the patent, describing the offenders in one fell swoop as "desktop and portable computers and servers." Apple has only been indirectly involved in the development of the chipsets in newer Macs, whose parts are largely Intel reference designs reshaped to match Apple's exotic designs.

OPTi has also developed a recent track record of dubious claims, say reports. The company filed a suit against processor maker AMD in the same Marshall, Texas court, claiming that it too was misusing predictive snooping. A third, earlier suit against an unnamed company was eventually settled out of court.

Neither the OPTi nor the Quantum cases are likely to reach their respective conclusions in the near future.

18 Comments ] 
  Print ] [ Story Link ] 



Mac Poker players can play Full Tilt Poker for Mac and get 100% to $600 free with bonus code MP600, courtesy of Online Poker Mac
AppleInsider Features
Hot Forum Topics

Recent Articles
Parallels takes virtualization speed crown in head-to-head with VMware
Apple releases iPhone OS 3.2 SDK for iPad
Apple seen extending exclusive iPhone deal with AT&T
iTunes price increases mean slower sales for music labels
Apple introduces 64-bit Aperture 3 with Faces and Places
Apple's share of U.S. smartphone market grows to 25% - study
iPhone OS 3.1.3 sees 14% adoption in 6 days, new hack released
Amazon rethinking Kindle in the wake of Apple iPad
Purported 4th gen Apple iPhone parts show largely unchanged design
Execs say Apple could lower iPad price if market demands it - report
Consumers lose interest in iPad after Apple's unveiling - survey
Higher Amazon e-book prices expected to coincide with iPad launch
Inside Apple's iPad: VGA video output
Unannounced Core i7 Apple MacBook Pro surfaces in benchmarks logs
Apple's new beta of Mac OS X 10.6.3 includes few changes
One in five physicians likely to purchase Apple iPad - study
Sling Media says it didn't change iPhone SlingPlayer to appease AT&T
Credit Suisse: 75% chance AT&T keeps iPhone exclusivity in 2010
Apple denying iPhone apps that use location framework for targeted ads
Apple's iPad deal gives Hachette pricing leverage against Amazon
Eccentric but effective Steve Jobs pitches iPad to NYT execs
Owners of flickering 27-inch iMacs claim 15% refund from Apple
IDC: Apple iPhone was No. 3 smartphone in 2009 with 14.4% of market
Future Apple iPhones could share current location during a call
AT&T, Sling Media partner to allow 3G access on iPhone SlingPlayer
Apple's iTunes Preview now offers browser-based App Store access
Amazon acquires touch-screen maker for future Kindle project
Nehalem Mac Pro systems suffer audio-based performance issues
Two new hires are Apple's latest moves in mobile advertising
AT&T outbid Verizon with cheaper Apple iPad data plans - rumor
Apple seen moving 2M iPads in 2010 before sales 'catalyst' emerges
Apple iPad deal pushes another publisher to renegotiate with Amazon
Apple allegedly selects new manufacturer for next-gen iPhone
ScrollMotion tapped by publishers to develop textbook apps for iPad
Apple denies iMac production halt as shipment times improve
Apple releases iPhone OS 3.1.3 with battery reporting fix
U.S. senator presses Apple on human rights practices in China
Photo of Apple's next-generation iPhone in the wild - sources
Despite sales growth, Apple's iPhone loses market share - report
Intel 6-core i7-powered Mac Pro rumored to launch this month

 
Advertisements








AppleInsider RSS Feed
AppleInsider © 1997-2008
Please review our Privacy Policy.
Written/Edited/Compiled by the AppleInsider Staff.